In the Name of Primacy

In 1973, Pierre Pescatore noted that “[P]rimacy is an ‘existential requirement’ of EU law”. The Opinion of AG Spielmann in Case C-448/23 (Commission v. Poland), delivered on 11 March 2025, opens with this harsh observation. His difficult task is to frame in legal terms the two essentially political rulings delivered by the Polish Constitutional Tribunal in 2021, where – notoriously – the “captured” domestic court refused to adhere to the most basic principles governing the relationship between national and EU law. This requires adjustments in the current vocabulary of the Luxembourg judges.

22. April 2025

, , , , , ,

Big Tech Antitrust Scrutiny Across the Atlantic

As Europeans await the European Commission’s enforcement of new tech rules, recent developments in the U.S. remind us that Big Tech scrutiny has been a transatlantic concern. On April 14, 2025, a trial began at the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia, where the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) is challenging Meta’s acquisitions of WhatsApp and Instagram under U.S. antitrust laws. This landmark case raises novel legal issues about mergers that were previously cleared a decade ago and highlights U.S. enforcers’ continued efforts to curb Big Tech power.

21. April 2025

, ,

Reforming the Legislature in Bangladesh

Bangladesh’s political journey since gaining independence in 1971 has shifted back and forth between democratic aspirations and periods of authoritarian rule. The country now stands at a crossroads again after its authoritarian leader, Sheikh Hasina, was ousted after popular protests last year. Tasked with the mandate of “rebooting democracy”, the Constitutional Reform Commission has proposed sweeping changes, including restructuring the legislature from a parliamentary to a semi-parliamentary system with moderation.

18. April 2025

,

Grundlegende Reform oder Schnellschuss?

Im März 2025 haben der Deutsche Bundestag und der Bundesrat einer Änderung des Grundgesetzes zugestimmt. Das am 24. März 2025 im Bundesgesetzblatt verkündete Gesetz sieht unter anderem vor, dass für Bund und Länder in den nächsten Jahren erhebliche neue Gestaltungs- und Verschuldungsspielräume entstehen sollen. Die Änderungen, die nach dem Entwurf des Koalitionsvertrages wohl noch nicht das Ende der Reformbemühungen darstellen, weisen einige offene Fragen und sprachliche Ungenauigkeiten auf, die Bund und Länder einfachgesetzlich weiter bearbeiten müssen.

18. April 2025

, , ,

Greenifying Copyright

Upcycling has become one of the trendiest buzzwords for people with a sustainability-oriented mindset. While the term might refer to various forms of recollection, improvement and reuse of data or (raw) materials, this post adopts a narrower focus. It is limited solely to reviewing how upcycling might be approached from a copyright perspective.

18. April 2025

,

Upcycling, the Ongoing Battle

In recent years, upcycling has seen a surge in popularity thanks to its positive impact on sustainability and the circular economy due to consumers’ increasing attention to the environment. As a result, individuals, artisans, and small companies have enthusiastically embraced the practice as a central part of their activities and a way to reduce waste. However, with fame often comes unwanted attention, and the growth of upcycling practices has led to various legal challenges against independent upcyclers based on the argument that their products violate intellectual property (IP) rights.

17. April 2025

,

The Opposition Erdoğan Can Tolerate

President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan is remaking Turkey’s opposition – not by defeating it outright, but by replacing it. His latest strategy appears to sideline the secular Republican People’s Party (CHP) and elevate the pro-Kurdish Peoples’ Equality and Democracy Party (DEM) as a more fragmented, controllable rival. This calculated manoeuvre could fracture the anti-Erdoğan bloc ahead of the 2028 elections while projecting an image of democratic pluralism.

17. April 2025

, , , , , , ,

Eben noch schnell den Kriegsdienst verweigern?

Im Koalitionsvertrag steht ein Modell für einen neuen Wehrdienst. Die jungen Menschen in Deutschland lehnen diesen aber mehrheitlich ab. Die Wehrpflicht ist dabei zwar eine Verfassungspflicht aller Bürger (nicht Bürgerinnen), gleichzeitig gibt es mit dem Grundrecht auf Kriegsdienstverweigerung eine außergewöhnlich starke Exit-Option für die Wehrpflichtigen. Diese ist auch im Verteidigungsfall sicher.

17. April 2025

, , , , ,

Governing in the Shadow of Indictments

Israel has been experiencing fierce conflicts between the Prime Minister and the government on the one hand and prominent public officials on the other. Two such conflicts have occupied the public discourse in recent weeks: the conflict between the government and both the Attorney General (Gali Barahav-Miara) and the head of the internal security service (Ronen Bar). In both cases, the government's attempt to remove these officials from office has run into legal difficulties, grounded in accusations concerning conflict of interest, which stem from two opposing principles within administrative law.

16. April 2025

, , ,

Money, Trust and Tools

Verfassungsblog faces the same challenges as any independent, non-profit, and community-led publication platform committed to Diamond Open Access (DOA). Recently, two projects were launched to strengthen DOA as a publishing model across borders and with a global reach. I attended the kick-off conference in Madrid to find out what we can learn from their approach, how we can benefit from their results and in what ways we can get involved to help shape the future of academic publishing.

16. April 2025

,