Thema: Demokratie & Institutionen

Verfassungsrechtliche Rahmenbedingungen für demokratische Regierungsführung, Gewaltenteilung, institutionelles Design und demokratische Prozesse. Umfasst die verfassungsrechtlichen Strukturen für Legislative, Exekutive und Judikative, Wahlsysteme, Föderalismus und verfassungsrechtliche Mechanismen demokratischer Rechenschaftspflicht.

The Basic Structure Doctrine, Article 370 and the Future of India’s Democracy

A constitution bench (five-judges) of the Supreme Court of India recently concluded the hearings related to the the abrogation of Article 370 of the Constitution and the bifurcation of the State of Jammu and Kashmir (J&K) into two Union Territories. How the Supreme Court finally decides this instant case will have far-reaching constitutional implications. In particular, the basic structure challenge pressed upon by the Petitioners, is likely to determine the future of India’s democratic federal architecture and the structural balance of power between the Union and states.

20. Oktober 2023

, , ,

Fördern und Fordern

Die Ampel-Koalition hat gemeinsam mit der Union einen Entwurf für ein „Stiftungsfinanzierungsgesetz“ (StiftFinG)vorgelegt. Mit dem vorgeschlagenen Gesetz soll die Grundlage für eine verfassungskonforme, mit der Rechtsprechung des Bundesverfassungsgerichts vereinbare Stiftungsfinanzierung geschaffen werden.. Darüber hinaus soll es für mehr Transparenz und Nachvollziehbarkeit der Finanzierungspraxis sorgen. Beides gelingt nur bedingt.

19. Oktober 2023

, , , , ,

Post-populist Populism

Good news for democracy from Poland? It appears that in the recent general elections, the right-wing populist Law and Justice party (PiS), won most seats but not enough to allow it to form a coalition. Donald Tusk's Civic Coalition has a better chance of forming a coalition, which might put an end to PiS' eight years of rule. This, prima facie, seems like a victory of democracy over populism. While this is certainly true, in this post we wish to flag certain warning signs that this possible democratic rotation is not the end of the struggle for democracy but merely the beginning of this process. This is because even when populists are voted out of office, their legacy - at least partially - persists.

19. Oktober 2023

, , , , ,

Degrees of (In)Dependence

For years, there has been a debate about making the Polish Prosecutor's Office an authority that is arguably located between the classic uniformed services (the police), public administration (tax offices), and the judiciary. In Polish scholarly discourse, two positions prevail regarding the place of the prosecutor's office in the system of state organs - subordination to the executive, or quasi-independence based on an organic statute with the strong influence of parliament. In this blog, I will explain how PiS has exploited Poland's adoption of the former model, and evaluate the promise and perils of a proposal to cure the current defects by rendering Poland's prosecutor's office (more) independent.

16. Oktober 2023

, , ,

Wehrhafte Demokratie

Die Rede von der „wehrhaften Demokratie“ bezog sich ursprünglich auf die militärische Wehrhaftigkeit nach außen. Das änderte sich mit Karl Loewensteins Überlegungen zur „Militant Democracy“ (1937)“, in denen es um die notwendige Wehrhaftigkeit der Demokratie nach innen ging, gegen den Faschismus, der ihr den Krieg erklärt hatte. In dem seither vorherrschenden innengerichteten Sinn gilt das Prinzip der wehrhaften oder, weniger prägnant, der streitbaren Demokratie heute in Deutschland als Verfassungsprinzip. Inzwischen haben wir in Deutschland eine sich zunehmend radikalisierende der Partei, die „Alternative für Deutschland“, die vom Verfassungsschutz als Verdachtsfall der Verfassungsfeindlichkeit geführt und deren thüringischer Landesverband vom thüringischen Verfassungsschutz als gesichert rechtsextrem eingestuft wird.

13. Oktober 2023

, , , ,

Halbwegs raus aus dem Hinterzimmer

Wenn der Deutsche Bundestag heute in erster Lesung über den Entwurf für ein Stiftungsfinanzierungsgesetz (BT-Drs. 20/8726) berät, setzt der Gesetzgeber zum Schlussspurt in einem eigenverschuldeten Wettlauf gegen die Zeit an. Hinter der Ziellinie wartet gewiss (mindestens) eine Klage vor dem Bundesverfassungsgericht, dessen verfassungsrechtliche Kontrolle der Gesetzestext nicht bestehen dürfte. Umso mehr überrascht die Planlosigkeit, mit der die politischen Akteure die vergangenen Monate haben verstreichen lassen.

13. Oktober 2023

, , ,

Reviving a Corpse

The political co-optation of the Constitutional Tribunal has eliminated its role in Poland’s checks and balances. The judges, although associated with the ruling party, are conflicted and some of them refuse to rule, the number of proceedings has fallen dramatically, and the Tribunal's authority has all but disappeared. It is not enough now to pick it up, shake it off, straighten it out, and put it back to where it was in 2015. Instead, if the opposition wins the election, it must rebuild an institution that is both an effective constitutional player, capable of checking the government and a trustworthy and reliable avenue for Polish citizens to assert their constitutional complaints. 

13. Oktober 2023

, , , ,

To Void or Not To Void

One of the most critical challenges in the process of restoring the rule of law in Poland after the period of ‘Law and Justice’ rule will be regulating the situation in the Constitutional Tribunal. After the unlawful election of three judges by the Sejm in November 2015 and the subsequent recognition of their judicial status by the new President of the Constitutional Tribunal, Julia Przyłębska, the Constitutional Tribunal lost its independence and authority. Instead of defending the Constitution and the rule of law, the Constitutional Tribunal often legitimizes controversial Government actions and openly questions the European standards. Rebuilding the Constitutional Tribunal's authority and restoring its proper functioning will undoubtedly be a challenging task. It must involve at least two actions: firstly, the removal of improperly elected individuals from adjudication and secondly, the regulation of the consequences of their judgments. In the following brief text, I will specifically address the latter issue, based on the report published by the Helsinki Foundation for Human Rights in June 2023.

13. Oktober 2023

, , ,

Judicial Transitology

The rule of law crisis in Poland consists of several elements – undermining the independence of courts, politicization of disciplinary proceedings against judges, and lack of legal certainty. None of them, however, raises so many doubts and concerns as the status of judges appointed or promoted upon the request of the politically captured National Council of Judiciary (NCJ). In this blog post, we analyse the diverse composition of the group of judges appointed or promoted upon the motion of the NCJ from 2018. We also discuss the relevant jurisprudence of national and international courts and the current state of debate concerning this problem and possible solutions.

12. Oktober 2023

, , , , ,

Poland’s Sham ›Migration‹ Referendum

On June 15, 2023, Jarosław Kaczyński, leader of Poland's PiS party, announced a rare referendum, ostensibly to allow the public to weigh in on crucial elements of Polish immigration policy, alongside the general elections. Yet, in reality, the referendum had little to do with migration and the opposition parties largely ignored the referendum's questions to avoid its deployment as an electoral campaign tool. As such, whatever voters will decide on Election day, it will tell us little about the state of Polish migration politics.

11. Oktober 2023

, , , , ,