Thema: Europarecht

EU-Verfassungsrecht, verfassungsrechtlicher Rahmen der europäischen Integration und Mehrebenenverfassungsrecht. Umfasst EU-Institutionenrecht, Grundfreiheiten, EU-Grundrechte, verfassungsrechtliche Aspekte der EU-Mitgliedschaft und das Verhältnis zwischen EU-Recht und nationalen Verfassungsordnungen.

Luxembourg’s Unworkable Test to Protect the Rule of Law in the EU

A key rule of law case illustrating the conversation taking place between national judges and the Court of Justice about the how-to of rule of law protection is the CJEU’s LM ruling dealing with the implementation of the European Arrest Warrant. In it the CJEU developed a test to balance mutual trust and individual rights, particularly the right to a fair trial. The Rechtbank Amsterdam and the Karlsruhe Oberlandesgericht applied Luxembourg’s LM test with respect to Polish suspects in a series of recent (interlocutory) rulings. This national case-law is interesting both for its immediate outcome (suspension of surrenders) and its implicit message to Luxembourg: “Sorry, we tried, but your test is unworkable.”

18. April 2020

, , ,

Infringement Procedures in the Time of COVID-19

In the last weeks, members of the European Parliament and observers in the legal and academic community have, explicitly or implicitly, criticised the European Commission and the Court of Justice for their handling of ongoing infringement procedures. Put simply, the two institutions have been criticised for moving the existing cases forward, despite the fact that certain countries (first Italy, then followed by almost all other Member States) are in lockdown and, consequently, their administrations are unable to effectively respond.

15. April 2020

, , ,

Not a Safe Place?

In an unprecedented move, the Italian government has declared Italy’s ports “unsafe” due to the COVID-19-pandemic. It did so by issuing an executive decree late Tuesday last week, seemingly in response to the rescue of 150 shipwrecked by the Sea-Eye’s Alan Kurdi. This is not the first time that the Italian government has used decrees to close its borders for sea-rescue ships. However, given the extraordinary circumstances of this case in the midst of the on-going Corona-crisis and the novel argument made by the Italian government, the decision warrants closer examination.

14. April 2020

, , ,

Solidarity and Constitutional Constraints in Times of Crisis

While important, European solidarity cannot take place at the expense of safeguarding citizens’ economic and social rights under the Constitution of Finland. For this reason, the Finnish Government needs to remain alert to the risks involved in the increasing financial commitments given by Finland. Depending on their exact features, the constitutional problems relating to “corona bonds” might only be overcome by a risky and time consuming constitutional amendment procedure. This is the result of two days of deliberations by the Constitutional Law Committee of the Finnish Parliament relating to the euro group agenda dedicated to the COVID19 crisis.

8. April 2020

, ,

Corona-Bonds: zu kurz gesprungen und dann auch noch in die falsche Richtung

In diversen Aufrufen werden gemeinsame Anleihen für die Länder der Europäischen Union gefordert, um die Folgen der Corona-Krise gemeinsam zu tragen. Mal werden sie Corona-Bonds (auch hier auf dem Verfassungsblog) genannt, mal Health-Bonds oder Renaissance Bonds. Und dabei wird nicht mit Pathos gespart: „Es gilt gerade jetzt, Wege zu finden, mit denen wir verdeutlichen können, dass wir zusammengehören, dass wir vom gleichen ‚Zauber gebunden sind‘, wie es in unserer Hymne heißt.“ Trotz aller Sympathie für die Motive der UnterstützerInnen, darunter so prominente Namen wie Jürgen Habermas, darf man aber kritisch hinterfragen, ob das wirklich ein geeignetes Instrument ist?

7. April 2020

, ,

Humiliating the Court?

The Member States, dismissing an Advocate General before the expiration of her term of office on the Court, have demonstrated that they are ready to humiliate the Court of Justice by allowing post-Brexit frustrations take the place of the Primary Law of the EU. The Rule of Law stands replaced with political whim. As AG Sharpston’s tenure is left in suspense, what is the worth of the core aspects of EU Rule of Law and judicial independence, when the Member States are willing to alter the composition of the Court by a political declaration?

7. April 2020

, , , ,

Die Zeit drängt

Viel zu lange hat die EU, die sich auf die Achtung der Menschenwürde gründet, die menschenunwürdigen Zustände in den Flüchtlingslagern zugelassen. Wenn nicht wenigstens einige EU-Mitgliedstaaten ihre Verantwortung für die in der Covid-19 Pandemie besonders gefährdeten Menschen in den Flüchtlingslagern auf den griechischen Inseln wahrnehmen, dann verliert die EU als Wertegemeinschaft jede Glaubwürdigkeit.

6. April 2020

, ,

The Case for Corona Bonds

Governments, economists and intellectuals have called for common European bonds or increased own EU funds to address the recession induced by Covid19. Unfortunately, the German government, joined by the other members of the “Frugal Four” (Austria, Finland, the Netherlands), has categorically rejected to look into any such measures and favours using the ESM. This reaction created a déjà vu experience for citizens and governments of the heavily affected southern Member States of the EU. The proposal to use the ESM raises fears of another wave of austerity amounting to yet another lost decade for economic, social, and ecological development in Europe.

5. April 2020

,